
Single-Unit vs Multi-Family Property Investment In Sapporo?
- 1. Buying a Single Unit Property Versus Buying a Whole Building in Sapporo
- 1-1. Which Has the Lowest Initial Cost?
- 1-2. Which is More Likely to Get a Loan from The Bank?
- 1-3. Which is More Profitable?
- 1-4. Which Property Values Are More Likely to Fall?
- 1-5. Which Investment Has Less Risk?
- 1-6. Which Offers More Freedom and Control of the Investment?
- 2. Sample of Property Replacement by an International Investor
- 2-1. Single Unit Ownership (the Condominium in Sapporo)
- 2-2. Reinvesting in a Whole Building Property
1. Buying a Single Unit Property Versus Buying a Whole Building in Sapporo
As a real estate investor decides what kind of investment property to buy, it is common for them to consider buying a single unit in a building (typically a condominium) or to buy a whole building (with multiple units).
The choice of whether to invest in a condominium or a whole building is also common as our clients invest in property here in Hokkaido. Both choices have their advantages and disadvantages, so let us compare the features of the two choices in six key areas. And then we will look at a specific example of a client of ours that recently decided to sell his condominium and instead buy a small building in Hokkaido.
1-1. Which Has the Lowest Initial Cost?
The primary advantage of buying a single apartment or condominium in Hokkaido is affordability.
Depending on the property and the location, investors can typically buy a single unit for less than the entire building. In Sapporo there are many second-hand studio flats priced below 10 million yen. For some people, this is a price range that can be bought with a lump sum of cash, making it easy for new investors to own property.
While single-unit investments are almost always less profitable, compared simply on the basis of sales price alone, it is usually true that the initial cost of condominium ownership is lower.
1-2. Which is More Likely to Get a Loan from The Bank?
To buy a multi-family building in Hokkaido typically takes more capital than to buy a single unit. Because of the higher purchase price, banks will carefully review any requests for loans.
However, as 'land' accounts for a large proportion of the price of whole-building ownership, the land is a powerful asset. The ability to use land as collateral (which does not usually decrease in value over time) commonly makes owning a building less risky and makes it easier to obtain financing than for a condominium unit.
Whereas financing for a single-unit purchase will depend more on the credit of the individual, when you buy a whole building, the value of the land itself can help with the approval process. This is applicable for permanent residents, special skilled visa holders, and other investors.
1-3. Which is More Profitable?
For a variety of reasons, investors that own the whole building typically have greater potential for profitability than investors that own single units in a building.
One reason is that when you buy a unit in a building, the building has shared maintenance and management fees that must be paid to the building each month. As an investor, if you own a single rental unit in a building you can collect rent, but you have to deduct these fees from your income each month, reducing your cashflow and return on investment. For this reason alone, many seasoned investors understand the profit is better in multi-family buildings.
1-4. Which Property Values Are More Likely to Fall?
For a condominium or a single building, which is more likely to lose value over time? This is relatively clear-cut: the value of single unit investments is generally more likely to decrease.
Property values for real estate other than land decline and deteriorates over time. The assessed value of real estate has an assessment standard known as the 'totalised assessment', which is calculated by adding up the land assessment and building assessment. In the case of a single-unit (what we call "sectional ownership" in Japan), there is almost no land valuation. For single-unit investments, the value is based mostly on the unit itself (the structure), which deteriorates, so the property value is deemed less valuable over time.
When you own the whole building, the land and building are assessed together. Even if the value of the structure declines due to deterioration, the value of the land rarely declines. While the performance of any given property depends on many factors; if you buy a single building in a good location, the value of the land will underpin the value of your asset.
1-5. Which Investment Has Less Risk?
Another disadvantage of buying a single-unit as an investment is a higher risk of loss of income from vacancy.
If you own one unit in a condominium and that unit is vacant, the occupancy rate will be zero and you will not receive any rent. Without rental income, you would be in the red if you had bought the property with financing. Owning a whole building helps you to spread the risk of vacancy.
For example, if you own a 10-unit building, and one of the units is vacant, the occupancy rate is still 90%. Even if there is some vacancy, you are still collecting rent from the other units. Multi-unit investment property in Sapporo and other cities in Hokkaido are more stable than single units.
1-6. Which Offers More Freedom and Control of the Investment?
In terms of the freedom to make decisions about your investment, owning a whole building is superior.
In a condominium with 100 units, you only have 1/100th of the rights in terms of decisions that affect that building. Even if you want to make improvements in the management of your condominium, you can only do so with the approval of the management association, which means that the degree of freedom is close to zero. The freedom to make repairs, etc. is limited to the rooms you own in your unit.
In contrast, with a multi-family investment in Hokkaido, you are free to maintain, renovate and remodel the building, including the exterior walls. You can also make your own decisions on the timing of implementation (referring to the opinions of the management company) which makes it easier to plan your finances.
2. Sample of Property Replacement by an International Investor
Here is an real example from one of our clients.
The client (introduced to us by Find Hokkaido Agents) is an American investor that bought a single unit condominium as a rental when he was unfamiliar with the Japanese market. He had some doubts about the profitability of the investment and consulted us to get some professional guidance to help with his goals of income-generating real estate.
We prepared some analysis for him for the expected returns on his single unit, versus the possibility of greater returns if he sold that unit and reinvested in a small multi-unit property. While there would be some cost in selling the condominium, it was clear he would have far greater monthly income (and greater control over his investment) with his own building.
Based on our recommendations, he sold his single-unit and bought a whole building.
Here are the actual numbers we used in the analysis of his investment choices:
2-1. Single Unit Ownership (the Condominium in Sapporo)
Gross Yield: 11.3%
Holding Period: 10 years
CCR:4.6%
After tax IRR:2.9%
2-2. Reinvesting in a Whole Building Property
Gross Yield: 12.5%
Holding Period: 10 years
CCR:8.6%
After tax IRR:6.2%
As a result, investment efficiency has improved and he has commented that he would like to increase the number of investment properties.
Real Estate Investment Consultation in Hokkaido
We are licensed real estate agents here in Hokkaido with experience helping clients and managing our own portfolio of investment properties. We help clients to understand how they can earn better returns on their investment capital.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation.
Your future investment property or home are just a step away with HOKKAIDO PROPERTY.
HOKKAIDO PROPERTY Website: https://hokkaidoproperty.co.jp/
Phone: +81-(0)11-600-6182
Email: info@hokkaidoproperty.co.jp

